COMPARISON
Rubber sheets and rubber-topped gym tiles
Compare three 24 square foot flooring options by construction, thickness, piece size and coverage.
EDITOR’S PICKS
Our top picks
Compare the size, setup, and limitations of each pick. Follow “Specs & sources” for the measurements behind it.
- 1Continuous rubber sheetRubber-Cal Elephant BarkAmazon
- 2Lower-profile tilesProsourceFit Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 1/2 inAmazon
- 3Thicker tile optionProsourceFit Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 3/4 inAmazon
#1Continuous rubber sheet
IllustrationFloor coverage
24 ft²
1 sheet · 0.2 in thick
Rubber-Cal
Elephant Bark
Black · 4 × 6 ft · 3/16 in
A single 4 × 6 ft sheet covers 24 ft² without an interior seam. Allow room for the full width when you lay it out.
#2Lower-profile tiles
IllustrationFloor coverage
24 ft²
6 tiles · 0.5 in thick
ProsourceFit
Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 1/2 in
Blue fleck · six 24 in tiles
Six tiles cover a nominal 4 × 6 ft rectangle. The half-inch profile takes less clearance under an opening door.
#3Thicker tile option
IllustrationFloor coverage
24 ft²
6 tiles · 0.75 in thick
ProsourceFit
Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 3/4 in
Blue fleck · six 24 in tiles
This pack covers the same area as the half-inch tiles and raises the surface by another quarter inch.
These three options each cover a nominal 24 ft² (2.23 m²). The Rubber-Cal sheet covers a 4 × 6 ft rectangle in one piece. Either ProsourceFit pack can cover the same rectangle with two rows of three tiles.
Compare the sheet and two tile packs
| Model | Construction | Thickness | One piece, L × W | Pack coverage | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ProsourceFit Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 1/2 inBlue fleck · six 24 in tilesLower-profile tilesCheck price on Amazon | Rubber surface over EVA foam | 0.5 in / 1.27 cm | 24 × 24 in / 60.96 × 60.96 cm | 6 tiles · 24 ft² / 2.23 m² | ProsourceFit flooring specificationsManufacturer-reported · |
| ProsourceFit Rubber Top Puzzle Mat, 3/4 inBlue fleck · six 24 in tilesThicker tile optionCheck price on Amazon | Rubber surface over EVA foam | 0.75 in / 1.91 cm | 24 × 24 in / 60.96 × 60.96 cm | 6 tiles · 24 ft² / 2.23 m² | ProsourceFit flooring specificationsManufacturer-reported · |
| Rubber-Cal Elephant BarkBlack · 4 × 6 ft · 3/16 inContinuous rubber sheetCheck price on Amazon | Recycled rubber sheet | 0.2 in / 0.5 cm | 72 × 48 in / 182.88 × 121.92 cm | 1 sheet · 24 ft² / 2.23 m² | Rubber-Cal flooring specificationsManufacturer-reported · |
Choose the layout
The 3/16 in Elephant Bark sheet has the lowest profile. Check the 48 in sheet width against alcoves and pillars. Both tile packs use a rubber surface over EVA foam and include edge strips. The half-inch and three-quarter-inch versions produce different floor heights, so keep thickness consistent where tiles join.
Measure under the door at the tightest point of its swing. Mark the feet of the rack and bench on the layout, and follow the equipment manufacturer’s requirements for the supporting floor and anchors. A tile’s thickness alone does not establish a drop rating or the load capacity of the floor beneath it.
Check a storage spot
The size finder checks one flat sheet or one flat tile. A six-tile pack and its borders need their own storage space. If you need a folding surface for floor exercises, compare folding exercise mats.